Wonderful news that the House left on Thursday for a twelve-day recess without approving Bush's immunity for the telecoms. If the phone companies violated the FISA law by allowing the government to spy and wiretap without a valid court-issued warrant, then they should face the music, both civil and criminal. Bush and Cheney have no right to grant them immunity. I suspect that the purpose of the telecom immunity is to shield Bush and Cheney themselves from evidence adduced in possible telecom suits that thse government officials broke the eavesdropping law with knowledge aforethought. So by proposing immunity for the telephone companies, Bush and Cheney are really trying to obtain immunity for their own illegal and reprehensible actions.
Friday, February 15, 2008
Thursday, February 14, 2008
RELEASE AL JAZEERA CAMERAMAN FROM GUANTANAMO WITHOUT DELAY
Nicholas Kristof has an op-ed in today's The New York Times on the Al Jazeera cameraman, Sami al Hajj, who has been held these last six years in Guantanamo. I have previously written about al Hajj on July 29, 2007.
There have been no charges made against al Hajj. According to Kristof, al Hajj is currently on a hunger strike to protest the unfairness of his imprisonment.
People can only guess why the U.S. military continues to hold al Hajj. Is it because Bush and Cheney hate Al Jazeera for airing the Arab side to the U.S. wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? Or is it because the U.S. military wants to punish al Hajj for taking photos of insurgents fighting the U.S. forces in Iraq?
Kristof quotes a Pentagon spokesman claiming that there is evidence against al Hajj:
"“There is a significant amount of information, both unclassified and classified, which supports continued detention of Sami al-Hajj by U.S. forces,” said Cmdr. Jeffrey Gordon, a Pentagon spokesman, adding that the detainees are humanely treated and “receive exceptional medical care.” "
Yet the U.S. refuses to release any such evidence. For all the public knows, al Hajj might be completely innocent. Therefore, the U.S. military must give al Hajj a chance to clear his name. If there is no credible evidence and if the U.S. refuses to bring charges, then al Hajj must be set free without delay.
No wonder the whole world hates the U.S. for its cruelty and unfairness towards prisoners at Guantanamo.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
7:50 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: DICK CHENEY, GEORGE W. BUSH, GUANTANAMO, NICHOLAS KRISTOF, SAMI AL-HAJJ, WAR IN IRAQ
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
BUSH SEEKS CONFESSIONS OF THOSE WATERBOARDED - BUT OF WHAT VALUE?
What is the matter with the mind set of Bush's political appointees and supporters? Justice Antonin Scalia says it is no simple question whether waterboarding is torture. Bush's Attorney General Michael Mukasey says he does not have enough information to tell whether waterboarding is indeed torture, but he will not hold an investigation into its legality. Republicans in Congress say they support "harsh interrogation methods," meaning waterboarding and torture.
Have these guys ever heard of the Inquisition that terrorized Europe between the 14th and 18th Centuries? How the Church suspected someone of being in consort with the devil, therefore church authorities put him on the rack and turned the screws until he confessed. Or how witches were given the "water treatment" until they admitted they were indeed witches commissioned by the forces of evil.
All these suspects did confess their allegiance to Satan, their diabolical powers, their conspiracy against God and his Church. Surely it must be the same with Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and the others. Waterboard them and they will surely confess.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
7:09 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: DICK CHENEY, GEORGE W. BUSH, HARSH INTERROGATION METHODS, INQUISITION, JUDGE MICHAEL MUKASEY, JUSTICE ANTONIN SCALIA, KHALID SHEIKH MOHAMMED, SATAN, WITCHES
Tuesday, February 12, 2008
16 SENATE DEMOCRATS SHAMEFULLY VOTE TO GIVE TELECOMS IMMUNITY
How could the U.S. Senate vote to give telecom companies immunity from possible violations of the FISA Act which prohibits spying on Americans without a court order or warrant?
William Branigin and Paul Kane report on-line for The Washington Post that:
"Senators voted 67 to 31 to shelve the amendment offered by Sens. Christopher J. Dodd (D-Conn.) and Russell Feingold (D-Wis.). A filibuster-proof 60 votes had been needed for the amendment to move forward.
"The vote represented a victory for the Bush administration and a number of telecommunications companies -- including AT&T and Sprint Nextel -- that face dozens of lawsuits from customers seeking billions of dollars in damages.
"Approval of the amendment would have exposed the companies to privacy lawsuits for helping the administration monitor the calls of suspected terrorists without warrants from a special court following the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks."
Here is the link to the roll call vote showing who voted for the final bill and who voted against. Sen. Clinton did not vote. Sen. Obama voted nay. All the Republicans and some 16 Democrats voted yea. Among the Democrats voting yea were Sen. Feinstein, Sen. Casey, Sen. Inouye, the two Senator Nelsons, Sen. McCaskill, Sen. Landrieu, Sen. Salazar, Sen. Lincoln, Sen. Conrad, Sen. Johnson, Sen. Kohl, Sen. Webb, Sen. Rockefeller, Sen. Pryor and Sen. Mikulski.
Shame on all these Democrats voting with Bush and the Republicans.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:14 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: FISA BILL, IMMUNITY FOR TELECOMS, SEN. BARACK OBAMA, SEN. HILLARY CLINTON
JUSTICE SCALIA SHAMES U.S. SUPREME COURT WITH HIS ACCEPTANCE OF TORTURE
When a sitting Supreme Court Justice defends acts of torture, how can anyone ever again criticize Bush and Cheney? They have a rock-solid defense. What we did and what we ordered, for example, waterboarding, is perfectly justifiable and beyond all legal question. Why? Because, Antonin Scalia, Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, backs us up and gives us legal cover.
In okaying torture and waterboarding, Scalia is truly reprehensible and without morals. Here is what he said according to the BBC:
"The most outspoken judge on the US Supreme Court has defended the use of some physical interrogation techniques. Justice Antonin Scalia told the BBC that "smacking someone in the face" could be justified if there was an imminent threat. "You can't come in smugly and with great self satisfaction and say 'Oh it's torture, and therefore it's no good'," he said in a rare interview."
Scalia uses the example of a nuclear bomb hidden somewhere in Los Angeles in his attempt to justify torture.
"To begin with the constitution... is referring to punishment for crime. And, for example, incarcerating someone indefinitely would certainly be cruel and unusual punishment for a crime."
"Justice Scalia argued that courts could take stronger measures when a witness refused to answer questions. "I suppose it's the same thing about so-called torture. Is it really so easy to determine that smacking someone in the face to determine where he has hidden the bomb that is about to blow up Los Angeles is prohibited in the constitution?" he asked. "It would be absurd to say you couldn't do that. And once you acknowledge that, we're into a different game.
"How close does the threat have to be? And how severe can the infliction of pain be?""
The problem is, Justice Scalia, suppose you torture the wrong person? Suppose you think that your suspect knows, but what happens if he really doesn't? Isn't this the same with the Inquisition where the Church handed over "heretics" to the ruling civil authorities who then used waterboarding or the rack to make them tell the "truth"? Suppose you yourself, Justice Scalia, were suspect and the authorities then waterboarded you to make you tell what you knew? Would you tell them that you were part of the 9/11 hijacking conspiracy? Would you tell them where the bomb in L.A. was hidden? Or would you allow them to torture you to death.
I suspect that Justice Scalia would be soon singing, telling his torturers what he thought that they wanted to hear, just to make them stop. Scalia calls it "so-called torture," so I guess he really doesn't think waterboarding qualifies. Why then, let's do it to him as a judicial experiment.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:45 PM PERMALINK
1 comments
Labels: JUSTICE SCALIA, TORTURE, WATERBOARDING
Monday, February 11, 2008
BUSH CALLS FOR EXTENSION OF TAX CUTS - BUT ECONOMY NEEDS SHORT-TERM STIMULUS LIKE EXTENSION OF EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS
George Bush comes out today and announces that the congress must do more to stimulate the economy, the same economy which Bush has for so long been calling "strong" and in good shape. Jeannine Aversa of the AP writes in today's The Washington Post:
"President Bush, acknowledging that the country is suffering through a period of economic uncertainty, called on Congress Monday to do more to help people and businesses hurt by the housing slump and credit crunch. . . .
"Bush again renewed his campaign for Congress to make his tax cuts permanent. "Unless Congress acts, most of the tax relief that we have delivered over the past seven years will be taken away and 116 million American taxpayers will see their taxes rise by an average of $1,800," the president said."
But Bush's tax cuts expire only in 2010. Bush will long since been gone, when any extension of these tax cuts would be effective. So how will that provide a short-term boost for an ailing and weak economy?
What Bush should call for is an extension of unemployment benefits for those out of work and an increase of food stamps for those in the lower income brackets.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:39 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: FOOD STAMPS, GEORGE W. BUSH, TAX CUTS, UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS
Sunday, February 10, 2008
SOME ISRAELIS CALL FOR DESTRUCTION OF GAZA VILLAGES AS RESPONSE TO MISSILES
Members of Israel Cabinet have been making irresponsible threats against the people and towns of Gaza in reaction to the incessant missiles falling in nearby Israeli towns and cities. The BBC reports that members have called for harsh Israeli response in the form of collective punishment against the Gaza population:
"Senior Israeli officials - including members of Mr Olmert's government - have demanded far harsher military and economic action in response to the continuing rocket barrages.
"The Israeli interior minister, Meir Sheetrit, said the army should choose a neighbourhood of Gaza, give its residents a day to leave, and then destroy it."
Destroying and razing a village would be unfair and a serious war crime under international law. No matter how much Israelis want the rockets to stop, Israel is not permitted to punish Gaza residents indiscriminately and/or collectively. Gaza children deprived of a home have not done anything to Israel and its citizens to warrant having their homes destroyed and themselves made homeless.
Israel should know that the wrong way to avenge the rockets is to demand an eye for an eye. Nothing can be solved by the use of military force. Shooting or killing Gazans or member of the Hamas party can do nothing except exacerbate the feelings for revenge and blood atonement.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
12:58 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT, GAZA, ISRAEL, ISRAEL CABINET
Saturday, February 9, 2008
REPUBLICANS AT CONSERVATIVE CAUCUS SHOUT OUT APPROVAL FOR TORTURE & WAR IN IRAQ
The New York Times today carries a story by Sheryl Lee Stolberg and Steven Lee Myers on the likely approach to be taken by the Republicans in supporting John McCain for president. The focus will be that the Democrats are weak and ineffective in combating terrorism.
The note was sounded by Mitt Romney in his exit speech when he said he was pulling out to prevent the Democrats from winning and surrendering to terrorism.
Bush and Cheney also made appearances this week at the Conservative Political Action Conference where they received wild cheers and ovations for, among other things, starting the war in Iraq, torturing prisoners at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib and who knows where else, gutting the protections of the Fourth Amendment, seizing more and more executive power, running roughshod over the Congress, and so on.
What truly amazed was the reaction from the attendees at the Conservative Political Action Conference. They cheered and clapped when Cheney said that he would order the harsh interrogation methods(read torture) again if needed, showing that the Bush/Cheney supporters have a deficiency when it comes to Constitutional and human rights. It is one thing for Bush and Cheney to be pro-torture, but it is an even worse indictment of their Republican supporters who shamelessly yell out their affirmations for what should be a reprehensible act in the light of fundamental ethics and morals.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:01 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: ABU GHRAIB, CONSERVATIVE POLITICAL ACTION CONFERENCE, DICK CHENEY, FOURTH AMENDMENT, GEORGE W. BUSH, GUANTANAMO, TORTURE, WAR IN IRAQ
Friday, February 8, 2008
WATERBOARD BUSH & CHENEY - GOD WILL PROTECT THEM IF INNOCENT BUT NOT IF GUILTY
The Bush Administration is pulling out all the stops in its efforts to justify its use of waterboarding. Saying that the CIA administered this classic torture technique on only three high value prisoners, Bush and Cheney want it to seem that they are judicious and prudent in nearly drowning only three out of many suspected terrorists.
Yesterday Cheney said if it were a matter of national survival he would again order suspects to be waterboarded.
Since Cheney seems to feel that the information produced by those subjected to the torture is worth it, I have a suggestion. Let's subject both Bush and Cheney to waterboarding. Let's see what information we can gather from them. Let's suspect them of being in consort with the terrorists. If they are indeed innocent, surely they will pass the water test without doubt. God himself will protect them, assuming they are innocent.
This is the very same test administered to those thought to have committed some crime back in the Middle Ages. Some suspects had to undergo a water test, others a test of fire, still others the rack. If they were indeed innocent, God would protect them from the rigors and pain of the trial, but if they were truly guilty, they would confess before the test was finished.
What is the difference between Bush and Cheney ordering waterboarding for certain suspects and the trials by fire, water and the rack some 800 years ago? Answer: there is no difference, they are exactly the same. That's why Bush and Cheney and their whole gang should be subject to waterboarding. If they are innocent, God will be with them. But if they are indeed guilty, God will not protect them and they will scream out in fear and pain.
Anyone want to take bets?
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
4:44 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: MIDDLE AGES, TORTURE, TRIAL BY FIRE, TRIAL BY RACK, TRIAL BY WATER, WAR ON TERROR, WATERBOARDING
Thursday, February 7, 2008
WHITE HOUSE TRIES TO SPIN ABSOLUTION FOR ORDERING TORTURE
The stuff coming out of the White House on waterboarding and how it isn't torture because some guys in the Office of Legal Counsel (read John Yoo and others) wrote a memo in which they said it wasn't - boggles the legal mind.
An opinion of the John Yoo cannot make something that exists not exist. It is not up to John Yoo to pass upon something like waterboarding and transform it into goldilocks like the alchemists of old.
Is waterboarding torture? We all know that it is. To say the opposite just won't pass the laugh test. If AG Mukasey and Intelligence Czar McConnell are unsure, then by all means they should volunteer to have themselves waterboarded.
Bush and Cheney and the rest of the gang will have some explaining to do in the near future. I mean before the International Court of Justice, and maybe even in front of a U.S. federal judge in the local district court. No self dealing will get them immunity from ordering the CIA to engage in torture.
By the way, I thought the Enlightenment in France in the Eighteenth Century put an end to such barbarisms and vestiges from the Inquisition. But no. Bush and Cheney have plunged Americans back into medieval days when trials by water and fire forced even the purest and most innocent to confess to unspeakable crimes.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
4:00 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: DICK CHENEY, ENLIGHTENMENT, GEORGE W. BUSH, INQUISITION, INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE, JOHN YOO, JUDGE MICHAEL MUKASEY, MICHAEL MCCONNELL, OFFICE OF LEGAL COUNSEL, TORTURE, WATERBOARDING
