Sandy Levinson writes in the legal blog Balkinization about our defective Constitution. Levinson points out how George W. Bush still can make lots of trouble not only for Americans but the rest of the world in his last three months in office, notwithstanding his low approval ratings and the disapproval of many in his theory of the "unitary executive." I commented on Levinson's post and here I reproduce some of my comments after editing.
The fact that even now on the eve of the presidential election Bush can still order missile strikes into Pakistani agrarian towns and villages is another reason why the Constitution needs amending.
We have today another example of Bush's dictatorial powers in a story from the website of The Washington Post as reported by Ishtiaq Mahsud:
"Suspected U.S. missiles slammed into two villages close to the Afghan border Friday, killing 27 people, including an Arab al-Qaeda operative and other foreign fighters, intelligence officials said.
"The strikes raised the number of such attacks to at least 17 since August. The surge has angered many Pakistanis and strained a seven-year U.S. alliance with Pakistan, where rising violence is exacerbating economic problems and undermining the nuclear-armed country's stability."
So it seems in his final days bellicose Bush is determined to antagonize the entire population of Pakistan in his quest to kill a few "Al Qaeda types." It doesn't matter how many innocents are killed at the same time provided that the target person is killed. In the story from the WaPo, we see at least 27 lives taken. Imagine how many innocent children and families lost their lives.
Additionally, I wonder how the CIA guy who pushed the button firing the missile into the targeted homes in Waziristan can sleep at night and whether he ever equates those children he killed with his own.
Some say this is legally justified by AUMF (Authorization to Use Military Force). But there must be a test of proportionality. To kill 27 people in order to kill one "Al Qaeda type" does not I argue meet this test. Furthermore, I submit that even killing of one innocent destroys the proportionality.
For this reason I find Bush's powers as president to order these strikes deeply troubling. Bush should have no authority to kill innocent civilians. His actions provide enough material to form the basis for charging him in the International Court with war crimes.
Saturday, November 1, 2008
DEFECTIVE U.S. CONSTITUTION ALLOWS BUSH TO RECKLESSLY FIRE MISSILES INTO PAKISTAN
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
3:42 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AL QAEDA, ATTACKS ON PAKISTAN VILLAGES, AUMF, BALKINIZATION, GEORGE W. BUSH, NORTH WAZIRISTAN, SANDY LEVINSON, U.S. CONSTITUTION
Thursday, October 23, 2008
U.S. AIRSTRIKE KILLS 8 MADRASSA STUDENTS IN PAKISTAN
Another military fiasco by the U.S. in Waziristan. American drones fired two missiles into a village madrassa, killing eight students.
The BBC reports on its web site:
"The school, in North Waziristan, is close to the residence of a fugitive Taleban leader, Jalaluddin Haqqani, witnesses told the BBC Urdu Service. At least two missiles, reportedly fired by pilotless US drones, hit the school early on Thursday."
Perhaps the U.S. was aiming the missiles at the Taliban leader but that is no consolation to the families of the dead students.
This whole military set of tactics that relies on the use of manned and unmanned aircraft needs to stop. It does more harm than good, and has made ordinary Pakistani villagers into allies of the jihadists and Talibanis.
When Obama is elected, I am hoping that he will put an end to the use of American war planes in both Pakistan and Afghanistan. The dropping of bombs or the firing of missiles from aircraft is notoriously imprecise, and almost always leads to unintended and cruel civilian casualties. It is totally unacceptable.
Writes the BBC:
"Witnesses told the BBC that the missiles destroyed nearly half of the school building in the Dande Darpakhel area near Miranshah, the main town in the North Waziristan tribal region.
"At least six people were injured in the attack, witnesses say. It is still not clear whether there were any foreign fighters among the dead students or whether it is linked to Mr Haqqani or his son, Sirajuddin.
"Local people have said that most of the injured were local students at the seminary. . . "
"In recent weeks the United States has launched many missile strikes against suspected militant targets in the Afghan border region.
"Washington says the strikes are used against militant targets, but correspondents say that intelligence failures have sometimes led to civilian casualties.
"Figures compiled by the BBC Urdu service show that some 80 people have been killed in a number of suspected US missile strikes in South and North Waziristan region over the past month.
"Earlier in October a suspected pilotless American drone fired missiles in North Waziristan, killing at least six people, Pakistani intelligence officials said."
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:42 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: NORTH WAZIRISTAN, PAKISTAN, U.S. BOMBING
