The New York Times has a report in today's paper by Dexter Filkins on the Afghan protests against combined U.S./Afghan military raids conducted several nights before. Afghan police apparently fired on the demonstrators and eight fell dead.
Writes Dexter Filkins:
"When the riot was over, at least eight protesters were dead and about a dozen wounded, shot by Afghan intelligence officers. Much of the town of Garmsir blamed the Americans.
"The episode, which American officers said they were investigating, highlighted how easily suspicions and resentment can flare out of control in an area as contested as the Helmand River Valley."
Juan Cole in his post today in Informed Comment places blame on the Taliban for inciting the villagers to near riot. Writes Juan Cole:
"Similar controversies over Qur'an desecration provoked anti-American rallies by the Muqtada al-Sadr group in Iraq some years ago. This cycle, of charges of foreign blasphemy, big rallies to protest it, and then the shooting of protesters, is a deliberate ploy by the Taliban to turn locals against NATO and the Afghan army."
I don't disagree with Juan Cole on the influence of the Taliban to stir up hornets nests against the American military. But I also feel that the American practice of conducting raids in the middle of the night which entail storming into homes of suspects, rousing the whole family, scaring the children, wrecking furniture and personal belongings, must of necessity lead to resentment and feelings of being humiliated.
Furthermore, many Afghans see American raids at 2 AM as violating the sanctity of their homes and especially offending their wives and women. This is no small matter in Afghan or Muslim society.
Dexter Filkins describes the events and aftermath of the raid:
"The protest began when several thousand Afghans gathered in the central bazaar in Garmsir, after reports of abuse by American servicemen during a raid at a nearby village two nights before. Local officials said the protest was organized by the Taliban’s shadow governor for Garmsir, Mullah Mohammed Naim.
"“The Taliban were provoking the people,” Kamal Khan, Helmand Province’s deputy police chief, said in a telephone interview. “They were telling the people that the Americans and their Afghan partners are killing innocent people, bombing their homes and destroying their mosques and also blaspheming their religion and culture.
"“The Taliban were telling the people, ‘This is jihad; you should sacrifice yourselves.’ ”
"No witnesses to the disputed raid could be located; it took place Sunday night in the village of Darweshan. American officers in Kabul said that Afghan soldiers conducted a nighttime operation in the village, with the Americans in support. But they said that no shots had been fired and that no one had engaged in any inappropriate conduct."
I thought Gen. Stanley McChrystal and Gen. David Petraeus were aware of the severe and lasting damage to U.S. interests that raids at 2 AM can cause. Consider how you would feel if foreign troops banged on your front door at that hour and forced their way into your home, saying that they were searching for weapons or other contraband. How would your children react?
That's why I want to see Pres. Obama order an immediate end to U.S. forces entering anyone's home after 9 PM.
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
U.S.RAID AT 2 AM ON AFGHAN VILLAGE LEADS TO RIOT AND DEATH OF EIGHT AFGHANIS
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
12:44 PM PERMALINK
1 comments
Labels: DEXTER FILKINS, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEN. MC CHRYSTAL, JUAN COLE, NIGHTTIME RAIDS, WAR IN AFGHANISTAN
Wednesday, April 9, 2008
PETRAEUS BLAMES IRAN FOR AIDING IRAQI "SPECIAL GROUPS"
Dana Milbank has a perceptive column in today's The Washington Post on the testimony yesterday of Gen. Petraeus.
"You can't tell the enemy in Iraq anymore without a scorecard.
"When the United States invaded Iraq five years ago, the enemy was Saddam Hussein and his Baathists. When Gen. David H. Petraeus and Ryan C. Crocker, respectively the U.S. commander and the ambassador to Iraq, came to testify to Congress last year, the enemy was al-Qaeda in Iraq. Yesterday, Petraeus and Crocker returned to Congress to report that the enemy had changed once again.
"We are now fighting Iran-backed "special groups" in Iraq.
""Unchecked, the special groups pose the greatest long-term threat to the viability of a democratic Iraq," Petraeus testified."
Who are these special groups? Surely Petraeus means the various Shiite Militias like the Badr Brigade allied with Prime Minister Maliki or the Sadrists under Moqtada al Sadr. But why call Shiite militias "special groups"?
Maybe to confuse the issue of Iranian aid for their Shiite co-religionists. Perhaps to give the false impression that Iran is backing Qaeda groups as well. Or other Sunni insurgents. All of which is pure bull.
But the Senators questioning Petraeus seem to have been taken up with all this talk about "special groups."
Reports Dana Milbank:
"The special talk caught the attention of Sen. Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.). "Is it fair to say that the Iranian-backed special groups in Iraq are responsible for the murder of hundreds of American soldiers and thousands of Iraqi soldiers and civilians?" Lieberman asked.
"It certainly is," Petraeus assured him.
"Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.) asked about the violence in Basra. Petraeus blamed the 107mm rockets of the "special groups." Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) asked about the Mahdi Army. Petraeus mentioned the "special groups." Sen. Mel Martinez (R-Fla.) asked about Iran. Crocker invoked the "special groups." Sens. Mark Pryor (D-Ark.) and Claire McCaskill (D-Mo.) also got the "special group" rate from the witnesses."
So all the talk about "special groups" allowed Petraeus and Ambassador Crocker, abetted by that war-monger, Joe Lieberman, to put all the blame on the lack of political and military progress in Iraq on Iran and its support for those "special groups." When you are losing battle, find a bogeyman to pin the blame. IRAN.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
3:12 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: ATTACK ON IRAN, BADR CORPS., GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, MOQTADA AL SADR, RYAN CROCKER, SEN. JOE LIEBERMAN, WAR AGAINST IRAN, WAR IN IRAQ
Monday, March 24, 2008
PETRAEUS BLAMES IRAN FOR ROCKET ATTACKS ON GREEN ZONE
The BBC reports that Gen. David Petraeus is accusing Iran of supplying the rockets and training the militants who attacked the Green Zone yesterday, the home of all the U.S. diplomats and big-shot military attaches.
Writes the BBC:
"The most senior US general in Iraq has said he has evidence that Iran was behind Sunday's bombardment of Baghdad's heavily fortified Green Zone.
"Gen David Petraeus told the BBC he thought Tehran had trained, equipped and funded insurgents who fired the barrage of mortars and rockets."
Where and when have we heard accusations of this nature before? Think of Iraq having WMD. Yet the U.S. and these generals never produce any credible evidence of Iran's involvement. They say they have the "evidence," but nobody ever gets to examine it. They expect the world to believe them just because they say it. Just like Bush expected the world to go along with his "evidence" that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction, and was an imminent "threat."
I don't believe anything Bush says, or anything that his hand-picked generals, such as David Petraeus, say. I want to see the "evidence" that they say they have. I want to know how they know that Iran "provided" the rockets and "trained" the insurgents. Until they provide credible evidence, I refuse to believe them and doubt that Iranian government is involved.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
12:36 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, IRAN, SADDAM HUSSEIN, WAR AGAINST IRAN, WAR IN IRAQ, WMD
Sunday, November 18, 2007
WASHPO SAYS SURGE "REMARKABLE SUCCESS" IN SPITE OF EVIDENCE TO CONTRARY
The Washington Post has an editorial today, entitled, "Don't Let The Surge Fail." You can imagine the message without reading one word. The surge is working. Bush and Petraeus deserve credit. The Democrats in Congress trying to stop the war are irresponsible.
Here's the first paragraph:
"THE EVIDENCE is now overwhelming that the "surge" of U.S. military forces in Iraq this year has been, in purely military terms, a remarkable success. By every metric used to measure the war -- total attacks, U.S. casualties, Iraqi casualties, suicide bombings, roadside bombs -- there has been an enormous improvement since January. U.S. commanders report that al-Qaeda has been cleared from large areas it once controlled and that its remaining forces in Iraq are reeling. Markets in Baghdad are reopening, and the curfew is being eased; the huge refugee flow out of the country has begun to reverse itself. Credit for these achievements belongs in large part to U.S. soldiers in Iraq, who took on a tremendously challenging new counterterrorism strategy and made it work; to Gen. David H. Petraeus, the architect of that strategy; and to President Bush, for making the decision to launch the surge against the advice of most of Congress and the country's foreign policy elite."
These are the same WashPo editorial writers that supported Bush's illegal Iraq invasion and occupation back in 2002 and 2003. Now they think the surge is working and Bush and Petraeus should be credit? It is too ludicrous. Consider the following from Reuters today on violence in Iraq. (Thanks to Juan Cole in his Informed Comment for pointing this out.)
"Following are security developments in Iraq at 1430 GMT on Sunday.* denotes new or updated items.*
BAGHDAD - The Iraqi army killed four gunmen and arrested 63 others during the last 24 hours, in different parts in Iraq, the Defence Ministry said.
MOSUL - A parked car bomb killed three people, including a woman, and wounded 16 others, including four policemen, when it targeted a police patrol in central Mosul, 390 km (240 miles) north of Baghdad, police said.
TIKRIT - A roadside bomb killed an Iraqi army officer and a soldier and wounded another while they were trying to defuse it in central Tikrit, 175 km (110 miles) north of Baghdad, police said.
BAGHDAD - Four bodies were found in different districts of Baghdad on Saturday, police said.
MOSUL - Five bodies, including that of a police captain, were found dumped in different areas of Mosul, 390 km (240 miles) north of Baghdad, on Saturday, police said.
BAGHDAD - A roadside bomb wounded two people in Ameen district of southeastern Baghdad, police said.
BAGHDAD - A roadside bomb hit a police commandos patrol near al-Tayaran Square in central Baghdad on Saturday, wounding two policemen, police said.
BAGHDAD - U.S. helicopters killed two men planting a roadside bomb south of Baghdad on Friday, the U.S. military said.
BAGHDAD - A roadside bomb wounded two people in Kesra neighbourhood in northern Baghdad, police said.
RUSTUMIYA - Several rockets or mortar rounds landed in Rustumiya neighbourhood in southeastern Baghdad but caused no casualties, police said."
The Washington Post says the surge is "working." The surge is a "remarkable success." Given the casualties listed in Reuters, the surge seems more of the unworkable same. Iraq is a catastrophe caused by the illegal and unjustified Bush war. Far from being a "remarkable success," it is wasting lives, both American and Iraqi, and needs to be stopped and ended. Congress cannot allow this foolishness to go on.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
10:06 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, SURGE, WAR IN IRAQ, WASHINGTON POST
Thursday, November 15, 2007
WALK IN BAGHDAD'S NEIGHBORHOODS IF SURGE IS WORKING
Republicans in Congress like to argue against a time table for withdrawing U.S. troops from Iraq. They say the surge is working and Gen. David Petraeus is a mastermind who needs more time to "finish" the job.
But this argument goes against reality. Juan Cole recites the figures:
"The House of Representatives attempted to put strings on Bush's latest supplemental for Iraq and Afghanistan, including a timetable for US military withdrawal. The bill they passed is expected to be defeated in the Senate and would in any case be vetoed by Bush. The Republican representatives are claiming things are just great now in Iraq (nearly 1000 persons a month are still being killed there even by the sketchy official statistics; as late as this September, the number of displaced persons increased by 16%; there is now active fighting on a new front, between Turkey and the Kurds holed up in northern Iraq; security is apparently collapsing in the port city of Basra; and Baghdad has in the past 10 months gone from 65% Shiite to 75% Shiite). Democrats warned against another 10 years of war at the cost of trillions of dollars."
There is no functioning Iraqi government outside the Green Zone. In neighborhoods in and around Baghdad, it is the law of the street and rule by war lords. Anything goes. As Juan Cole points out, there are still over 1,000 people killed per month. Iraqis are still streaming out of their neighborhoods. And Baghdad has witnessed ethnic cleansing on an enormous scale.
Ghaith Abdul-Ahad writes in The Guardian on his personal observations and experiences in one Baghdad neighborhood.
Here is one vignette from this must-read account by Adul-Ahad:
"Ameriya is a closed zone, surrounded by high concrete walls. Only pedestrians are allowed through the two Iraqi army checkpoints out of the suburb. The "knights" are the only authority inside.
"When we arrived at the house where the alleged al-Qaida commander was hiding, Bakr was already in action. He was dragging a plump man into a car, grabbing his neck with one hand and his BKC machine gun with the other.
"The horrified man begged them not to take him. "By Allah, I didn't say Qaida is better than you, you are our brothers, just let me go!" A gunman kicked the man and pushed him into a car.
"The suspect's brother, still in his pyjamas, pleaded, and women in nightgowns stood in the street wailing and begging the gunmen to release him.
"The gunmen pointed their guns at the people and pushed them back. A young fighter carrying an old British sub-machine gun fired a burst into the air."
Read Adul-Ahad's report and then compare it with the Republicans and their vacuous pie-in-the-sky comments on the "surge is working" theme.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
10:39 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: BAGHDAD AIRPORT, GAHITH ADUL-AHAD, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, JUAN COLE, SURGE, WAR IN IRAQ
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
NEO-CONS LOOK TO DEMONIZE AND ATTACK IRAN
Sometimes articles appear that cause me the reader astonishment. Such is the article by Richard Cohen in today's The Washington Post. Called "Bush's Legacy of Cynicism," it starts out bemoaning Bush's policies which have cause the lack of credence put in government many of us share.
So far so good. But then Cohen goes on to say how real the "threat" is from Iran and from the Revolutionary Guard. So Cohen's article is not about the duplicity of George Bush and Dick Cheney and their minions. It is really a call to arms against Iran. Here's Cohen:
"But the true realism is that Iran is a menace -- potentially a great one -- and that its Revolutionary Guard is engaged in the dirty business of killing Americans and others. The fact that the Bush administration says so does not make it otherwise."
Cohen apparently was gung-ho for the war against Iraq. Now he is breathless for a war against Iran. He says we have "evidence."
"As the resolution states, the American military has "evidence" -- the word is Gen. David Petraeus's -- of Iranian activity. "This is not intelligence," the general told Congress. "This is evidence, off computers that we captured, documents and so forth." Petraeus didn't get his stars for nothing. He knows the level of well-earned cynicism that the word "intelligence" now engenders in Congress. Evidence! He's talking evidence."
Mr. Cohen, you talk about "the true realism . . . that Iran is a menace." And then you talk about "evidence." If Bush, Cheney or Petraeus had hard evidence, they would be besieging the news media morning, noon and night with it. There is no "evidence" that Iran is supplying IEDS or EFPs. Any garage in Baghdad is capable of fashioning these explosives, and probably do. Just because Petraeus says we have "evidence" does not make it so, any more than Bush, Cheney and Rice claiming Saddam had WMD.
You would take us to war with Iran over non-existent evidence? You would have the U.S. Senate endorse a resolution saying that Iran is killing American soldiers solely on the basis of what some Bush loyalist says or claims?
No thanks, Mr. Cohen. This time, I for one am not buying into your pie-in-the-sky demonization of Iran and Iranians. Instead of attacking or bombing Iran, let's sit down and begin to talk with them. I remind you, this is the year 2007, not 1007.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
12:36 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CONDOLEEZA RICE, DICK CHENEY, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, RICHARD COHEN, WAR AGAINST IRAN, WAR IN IRAQ, WMD
Monday, October 29, 2007
WHO AUTHORED MEAN DEMEANING E-MAILS SENT TO BLOGGER GLENN GREENWALD?
I like to direct my readers to Glenn Greenwald at Salon. com. Glenn has received several e-mails from Col. Steven Boylan, public relations aid to General Petraeus in Baghdad. The bizarre element to this exchange of e-mails is that Col. Boylan seems to say that he did not send them and that they are forged fakes.
Writes Greenwald:
"There are only two possibilities, both of which are self-evidently newsworthy. Either:
(1) Col. Boylan sent me that first polemical, blatantly politicized email and then falsely denied having sent it, or,
(2) someone has the extraordinary ability to fabricate emails which have every appearance -- even to advanced computer experts -- of being authored by and sent from the computers of some of our highest-ranking military officials in Iraq (or, worse, to obtain direct access to their Centcomm computers), a possibility about which Col. Boylan expressed total indifference and then refused to address.If someone really is able to replicate emails from high-ranking military officials in Iraq, think about what a serious breach that is. Can the fabricators also send emails to commanders in the field or to political decision-makers in Washington?"
From comparing the e-mail addresses and route information on the "Boylan e-mails," they seem to be the same as that originating from e-mails that Boylan does admit to have sent. After reading the e-mails sent to Greenwald, perhaps one explanation of Boylan's reluctance to accept authorship is that they are full of mean put-downs and irrational non-sequiturs. It is one think to argue a point with legitimate argument, another to personally disparage the person with whom you argue.
Read the "Boylan e-mails" and then come to your own decision about Boylan's style and modus operandi. I think you will agree with me that the author of the "Boylan e-mails" sent to Greenwald is most comfortable when he can disparage and demean.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
4:53 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: COL. STEVAN BOYLAN, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GLENN GREENWALD
Sunday, October 7, 2007
PETRAEUS CLAIMS IRAN IS SUPPLYING WEAPONS BUT WHERE IS THE PROOF?
Now we have the top general himself, David Petraeus, coming out and accusing Iran or meddling in Iraq and killing U.S. soldiers.
Dean Yates of Reuters writes in The Washington Post:
"General David Petraeus, speaking at a U.S. military base about 30 km (20 miles) from the Iranian border on Saturday, said Iran was giving advanced weaponry to militias in Iraq.
""They are responsible for providing the weapons, the training, the funding and in some cases the direction for operations that have indeed killed U.S. soldiers," Petraeus told a small group of reporters when asked if the Iranian government was responsible for killing U.S. troops."
Petraeus said he was sure that Iran was involved:
""There is no question about the connection between Iran and these components, (the) attacks that have killed our soldiers.""
Once again we see and hear these charges from U.S. generals and administration officials, but where is the evidence? Petraeus gives no solid or creditable evidence of Iranian involvement, except to say that Iran is training and arming Iraqi militias.
Writes Dean Yates:
"But Petraeus said he had no doubts about the Qods force.
""There should be no question about the malign, lethal involvement and activities of the Qods force in this country," he said. Petraeus listed the type of weapons he said Iran was supplying to militias in Iraq. He said this comprised advanced rocket-propelled grenades, shoulder-fired "Stinger-like" air defense missiles and 240mm rockets. This was in addition to components used to make explosively formed projectiles (EFPs), a particularly deadly roadside bomb that has killed hundreds of U.S. troops in Iraq."
Let's examine the "evidence" cited by Bush's man, Petraeus.
First the EFPs that Petraeus says are being supplied by Iran. There must be hundreds of cellars and workshops in Iraq that can make and tool these explosively formed projectiles. Most Iraqis hate the U.S. occupation and sympathize with the insurgency of whatever form. There is no way to say that these EFPs come from Iran and not from within Iraq.
Second, how do we know advanced RPGs come from Iran? Once again, the U.S. military just relies on assertions without any creditable evidence backing up their assertions.
Third, how about the stinger-like air defense missiles and rockets? How do we know they do not come from Saudi Arabia rather than from Iran? The answer is, we don't because the Petraeus has not made his case. Furthermore, if Iran were supplying these weapons, every U.S. helicopter and aircraft in Iraq would be in constant danger of being shot down. It is not clear that this is the case.
Petraeus needs to back up his reckless assertions with proof. So far, he has been reckless on his statements but short on the proof. It would seem once again he is being used by Bush and Cheney to demonize Iran and to make it the enemy in preparation for a U.S. strike. We must not allow this to happen
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
10:26 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, IRAN, WAR AGAINST IRAN, WAR IN IRAQ
Thursday, September 20, 2007
BUSH CRITICIZES MOVE-ON.ORG AD ON PETRAEUS
Michael Abramowitz reports in today's The Washington Post that Mr. Bush condemned the MoveOn.org ad which questioned whether Gen. Petraeus is really "Gen. Be-tray-us."
Writes Abramowitz:
"President Bush today condemned the recent MoveOn.org advertisement that described Army Gen. David H. Petraeus as General "Betray-Us," voicing disappointment that leading Democrats had not denounced it as well.
"In his first public comments on the newspaper ad that appeared last week in the New York Times, Bush said more Democrats " are afraid of irritating a left wing group like Moveon.org . . . than they are of irritating the United States military. That was a sorry deal.""
Bush is trying to concoct a political argument where he stands besides and behind the U.S. military. Doesn't he know that in the United States the military is the servant of civilian authorities? This means civilians can criticize if they want generals and other military officers. Otherwise, if it were improper, the military would be the dictators of American society.
MoveOn's director responded to Bush's phony criticisms. Abramowitz writes:
"MoveOn.Org's executive director, Eli Pariser, reacted sharply to Bush's comments this morning. In an interview, he said: "What we think is disgusting and outrageous is that the president is more interested in political attacks than he is in an exit strategy that will get our troops home swiftly and quickly." "
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
11:59 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, WAR IN IRAQ
Sunday, September 16, 2007
FRANK RICH, LIGHTEN UP ON MOVE-ON.ORG
Frank Rich in his column (subscription required) in today's The New York Times takes a swipe at the Move-on.org democrats who ran the "General Be-tray-us" ad. Lighten up, Frank. By the way, have you taken a close look at the ad? It actually poses a question, "General Petraeus or General Betray Us?"
Okay, I agree it is a bit juvenile to play around with someone's last name. However, Gen. Petraeus is a public figure and has inserted himself into the political arena by being a spokesman for George Bush.
Furthermore, I submit Move-On is asking a legitimate question. Is David Petraeus going to serve merely as Bush's political hack and front man, or is he going to tell the truth that the War in Iraq is beyond winning, a bloody result of the catastrophic mistake of Bush's foreign policy?
Or do critics of Move-on.org including Frank Rich think citizens should never criticize generals or army officers who wear lots of ribbons? This reminds me of the reaction of churchmen when someone criticizes their doctrine or their life style. They react by accusing the critics of disrespect for authority. Here we get the same reaction from people, mostly Republicans, who again cry disrespect.
Remember the generals report to civilians in the United States, and they are servants of American civilians. When those civilians ask hard questions of the generals, please don't be like the church authorities and try to squelch the criticisms in place of answering the complaints with reasoned arguments.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
10:11 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: FRANK RICH, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, MOVEON.ORG
Friday, September 14, 2007
RUDY BRISTLES AT MOVE-ON.ORG AND HILLARY FOR CRITICIZING (GASP!) GEN. PETRAEUS
According to Michael D. Shear in The Washington Post, Rudy Giuliani is planning to spend money to place newspaper ads attacking MoveOn.org and Hillary Clinton for their criticisms of Gen. David Petraeus. MoveOn ran a full page ad in The New York Times calling him "Gen. Betray-us." Hillary expressed scepticism over the rosy picture of "progress" in Iraq which Petraeus was giving the congress at the beginning of this week.
Hasn't Rudy ever heard of civilian control of the military? I know George Bush has abdicated his responsibility to the "generals," but why should Rudy think the rest of us are going to bow down every time a general walks by or speaks?
Maybe Rudy knows that the army is powerless to fight a war when civilians are against it. So maybe Rudy is trying to minimize perceived civilian discontent with the hated War in Iraq, so that the army can continue to fight Iraqis.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:56 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, MOVEON.ORG, RUDY GIULIANI, SEN. HILLARY CLINTON, WAR IN IRAQ
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
PETRAEUS CLAIMS IRAN IS SUPPLYING WEAPONS TO SHIA INSURGENTS IN IRAQ
Gen. David Petraeus appeared at the National Press Club today together with Ambassador Ryan Crocker. Petraeus had some bad things to say about Iran. William Branigin reports on Petraeus' comments on the web page of The Washington Post:
"Asked whether his testimony about Iran could be viewed as part of a campaign to build toward an attack, Petraeus said: "I'm not blaming Iran for all that's gone wrong in Iraq." But he said Iran has contributed to sophisticated attacks in Iraq that otherwise would not be possible, including strikes with armor-piercing "explosively formed projectiles" and 240mm rockets."
Yet we know the military has offered no verifiable proof or evidence that the government of Iran is involved. Petraeus claims there is clear evidence.
Writes Branigin:
""The evidence is very, very clear," Petraeus said. He cited documents discovered during the capture in March of Qais Khazali, a Shiite Muslim militant with ties to the Quds Force of Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps, and the arrest of a deputy commander of Hezbollah, the militant Lebanese Shiite group supported by Iran. Petraeus said the evidence links Iran to an attack in Karbala in January that resulted in the deaths of five U.S. soldiers.
"Under interrogation, Khazali was asked if he could have carried out that attack without Iranian support, Petraeus said in the news conference. "He literally throws up his hands and laughs and says, 'Of course not,' " the general said.
"Khazali and other captives have told U.S. investigators about funding, training, weapons and ammunition they had received from Iran, he said."
But the evidence is not "very, very clear." On the basis of one captured Shiite Muslim throwing up his hands who laughs and says of course not? Is this the extent of it?
Gen. Petraeus, sir, how about answering the following questions? Has this guy Khazali been deputized by the Iranian mullahs? Has he received anything from the government of Iran? Has he actually himself been a trainee in an Iranian training camp? Khazali is an officer in Hezbollah, but so what? What does that prove about any alleged Iranian involvement? Is the involvement an ad hoc arrangement where members of the same Shiite tribe help one another financially or militarily, no matter that some members live across the border in Iran and some live in Iraq?
To think that Bush and Cheney, and even Petraeus, base their claim of Iranian involvement in the civil and anti_U.S. bloody strife in Iraq on one guy, Khazali who really says very little about Iranian involvement! And this is going to be a casus belli for the American neo-cons to bomb and attack Iran and kill hundreds and thousands of Iranians!
So far the United States government and military have offered no creditable evidence that Iran is sending in powerful explosive-shaped charges or IEDs, notwithstanding the bellicose comments of Joe Lieberman and Dick Cheney and the other Republican war mongers. When we analyze their statements, all we get are accusations lacking reasonable basis and innuendos demonizing Iran and Iranians.
Is it too much to ask of our leaders that they sit down with those countries perceived to be "enemies" and work things out through peaceful negotiation and diplomacy? The United States should engage in peaceful relationships, not in bloody and murderous acts of war.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:12 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AMBASSADOR RYAN CROCKER, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, NEO-CONS, WAR AGAINST IRAN, WAR IN IRAQ
Monday, September 10, 2007
PETRAEUS FIGURES ON IRAQI CIVILIAN CASUALTIES BEAR NO RESEMBLANCE TO THOSE OF AP OR IBC
I found these charts on TPM Muckracker showing numbers for civilian casualties in Iraq for 2006 and 2007. They bear no resemblance to the figures offered today by Bush's military spokesman, Gen. David Petraeus. The numbers come from the Associated Press and from "Iraq Body Count," a British organization. In both the AP and IBC, it is crystal clear that the civilian casualties in Iraq are up over 2006 FOR EVERY SINGLE MONTH.
And on Talking Points Memo, David Kurtz plots out on a graph the numbers given today by Petraeus. Where has Petraeus obtained his figures? For every single month this year, the Petraeus figures show lower civilian casualties.
So whom to believe? Petraeus who works for Bush and whose neck is on the chopping block to show the "surge" is making progress? Or the Associated Press and IBC?
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
4:20 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, IRAQI CIVLIAN CASUALTIES, WAR IN IRAQ
PETRAEUS CLAIMS SURGE IS WORKING BUT GIVES NO HARD EVIDENCE
Petraeus is living up to expectations by claiming that the surge is working. And the Republicans in congress are falling over themselves praising him. Okay, Let the Republicans be the party that embraces the War in Iraq. Let's take the issue into the next elections. By that time, there will still be approximately the same number of U.S. troops in Iraq, no matter what Petraeus says about a draw-down. There will still be deaths of U.S. soldiers from IEDs and other violent attacks. There will still be sectarian violence raging throughout Iraq. Let the Republicans constitute the party in favor of the War in Iraq. Let them who want to keep this war going explain "progress" then.
William Branigin and Robin Wright write for The Washington Post that Petraeus claims that there has been a decrease in violence since the surge began.
"Appearing with the top U.S. diplomat in Iraq to report to Congress on military and political developments in the four-year-old war effort, Army Gen. David H. Petraeus claimed major progress for the so-called "surge," the deployment of an additional 30,000 troops to Iraq last spring.
"Citing a drop in the overall level of violence in Iraq, Petraeus said, "I believe that we will be able to reduce our forces to pre-surge levels . . . without jeopardizing security gains we fought so hard to achieve." He said he also believes that "it is possible to achieve our objectives in Iraq over time," although this will be "neither quick nor easy.""
Note that neither Wright or Branigin give numbers or figures offered by Petraeus backing up his claim. Furthermore, these main stream reporters from the WashPo seem to accept without questioning Petraeus' argument that the surge is working and that there has been a drop in the overall level of violence in Iraq.
Petraeus can't give numbers because his claim is specious spin, designed to give Bush and the whole Republican Party cover in their attempt to foist Bush's foreign policy catastrophe off to the next president.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:47 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, WAR IN IRAQ
FROOMKIN ASSEMBLES QUESTIONS FOR PETRAEUS AND CROCKER
Dan Froomkin today in his White House Watch in The Washington Post assembles questions suggested by news organizations and commentators for Gen. David Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan Crocker who are testifying today before Congressional panels.
Froomkin notes that the appearances today by Petraeus and Crocker are merely charades, and that Bush is not going to change his tactics or strategy, because he hopes to prolong the War in Iraq until at least he is out of office.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
12:42 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AMBASSADOR RYAN CROCKER, DAN FROOMKIN, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, WAR IN IRAQ
Friday, September 7, 2007
PETRAEUS SAYS U.S. HAS KILLED "THOUSANDS" OF AL QAEDA IN IRAQ
Gen. David Petraeus has written a letter to the troops, reprinted in today's The Washington Post. Really, the letter is intended as propaganda intended for the American public, with the message that the surge is working real progress in Iraq. The letter is however replete with exaggerations and simplifications.
Petraeus makes it seem that the number one threat in Iraq is AQI. He mentions Al Qaeda at least five times, such as "thousands of members of Al Qaeda" being killed or captured by U.S. forces.
My question for Gen. Petraeus: how many members of AQI do you think are in Iraq? General, may I suggest you look at Andrew Tilghman's piece for Washington Monthly about this very point. According to the experts, Tilghman finds that there are only about 850 members of AQI, and that number is probably on the high side.
Writes Tilghman
"To describe AQI's presence, intelligence experts cite a spectrum of estimates, ranging from 8 percent to 15 percent. The fact that such "a big window" exists, says Vincent Cannistraro, former chief of the CIA's Counterterrorism Center, indicates that "[those experts] really don't have a very good perception of what is going on."
"It's notable that military intelligence reports have opted to cite a figure at the very top of that range. But even the low estimate of 8 percent may be an overstatement, if you consider some of the government's own statistics . . . "
"How big, then, is AQI? The most persuasive estimate I've heard comes from Malcolm Nance, the author of The Terrorists of Iraq and a twenty-year intelligence veteran and Arabic speaker who has worked with military and intelligence units tracking al-Qaeda inside Iraq. He believes AQI includes about 850 full-time fighters, comprising 2 percent to 5 percent of the Sunni insurgency. "Al-Qaeda in Iraq," according to Nance, "is a microscopic terrorist organization.""
So what then does Petraeus mean when he congratulates his troops and says that they have killed or captured "thousands" of Al Qaeda members?
This is just hype, just spin, just propaganda. Why does Petraeus emphasize Al Qaeda in his letter? For the same reason George Bush does, to conflate 9/11 terrorists with the insurgents fighting U.S. troops in Iraq. We all know there is no connection. The Iraqi insurgents want the Americans gone, want the tanks gone, want foreign occupiers gone. They fight the U.S. troops because they are invaders and occupiers, not because they espouse bin Laden's view of Islam.
Petraeus is playing a dangerous game, the same one Bush is playing. Politicizing the war so that history will have trouble blaming these politicians and these generals for the worst catastrophic mess-up in U.S. history.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
10:32 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AL QAEDA IN IRAQ, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, WAR IN IRAQ
Friday, August 31, 2007
GAO PAINTS BLEAK PICTURE OF BUSH'S "PROGRESS" IN IRAQ
So now that the GAO has found that Iraq has missed or failed in 15 of 18 congressionally mandated benchmarks, the White House and the Pentagon are disputing the findings. In other words, fit the evidence around the policy. If the report is not what Bush and Cheney want to hear, then change it!
Karen DeYoung and Thomas E. Ricks write in yesterday's Washington Post:
"Iraq has failed to meet all but three of 18 congressionally mandated benchmarks for political and military progress, according to a draft of a Government Accountability Office report. The document questions whether some aspects of a more positive assessment by the White House last month adequately reflected the range of views the GAO found within the administration.
"The strikingly negative GAO draft, which will be delivered to Congress in final form on Tuesday, comes as the White House prepares to deliver its own new benchmark report in the second week of September, along with congressional testimony from Army Gen. David H. Petraeus, the top U.S. commander in Iraq, and Ambassador Ryan C. Crocker. They are expected to describe significant security improvements and offer at least some promise for political reconciliation in Iraq."
This is truly embarrassing for Bush & Co. We know that the White House is writing the report to be given by Petraeus and Crocker, notwithstanding Petraeus' protestations that he is writing his own report. And we can predict the content of the WH report: good progress is being made in Iraq; the Iraqis are standing up so Americans can stand down; Al Maliki is creating a unity government, etc., etc. ad nauseam. Does Bush think that anyone really believes his spin? Even Republicans must cringe when they hear Bush's propaganda on how good things are going in Iraq.
Karen DeYoung writes a follow-up in today's WashPo:
"Democrats seized on the GAO draft conclusions, first reported in yesterday's Washington Post, to warn that President Bush would be likely to distort the Iraq situation when he makes his own report to Congress in mid-September after long-awaited testimony by Gen. David H. Petraeus, the U.S. commander in Iraq, and Ambassador Ryan C. Crocker. "As in the past, President Bush stubbornly refuses to acknowledge the facts on the ground about the sectarian civil war in Iraq or the growing bipartisan opposition to his failed policies," House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said in a statement.
"Pelosi cited negative conclusions in the GAO report and last month's National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq to say that "the Iraqi government has failed to achieve required reforms." Influential Republicans have joined Democrats in recent months to demand that Bush begin drawing down U.S. troops. Bush has argued that the strategy he announced in January, which increased the U.S. presence to more than 160,000 troops, is succeeding and deserves more time."
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
8:01 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AMBASSADOR RYAN CROCKER, GAO, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, NANCY PELOSI, WAR IN IRAQ
Thursday, August 16, 2007
BUSH TRIES TO MINIMIZE TESTIMONY OF PETRAEUS TO CLOSED DOOR SESSION
Jonathan Weisman and Karen De Young write in The Washington Post today that the White House (i.e., George Bush and Dick Cheney) want to restrict the testimony of "my man David" (Gen. David Petraeus) and Ambassador Ryan Crocker to a closed-door Congressional briefing. In their place giving the "report on progress" before the full Congress would be the Secretary of State, Condoleeza Rice, and the Secretary of Defense, Robert Gates.
"Senior congressional aides said yesterday that the White House has proposed limiting the much-anticipated appearance on Capitol Hill next month of Gen. David H. Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan C. Crocker to a private congressional briefing, suggesting instead that the Bush administration's progress report on the Iraq war should be delivered to Congress by the secretaries of state and defense."
The question can only be why?
It is obvious that Bush/Cheney want to restrict Petraeus and Crocker to the background because they fear the truth these guys would present. Iraq is a disaster, the worst foreign policy blunder of the United States in in 221 years of existence. It is a black hole that continues to grow deeper and darker. There is no chance for military victory in Iraq, no chance to quell the Sunni-Shia violence, no chance to establish or help to organize a representative government.
Is Iraq better off since Saddam Hussein was overthrown by invading American troops? No way! It is so much worse off. Ask any Iraqi who has lost a father or son, wife or child, wither from the itchy trigger fingers of the U.S. troops or from the sectarian blood-letting. Ask any one of the relatives of the 650,000+ Iraqis who have been killed since the invasion if Iraq is better off now than under Saddam.
And how about the 3,600+ American soldiers who have lost their lives in Iraq? Why? To preserve freedom? Freedom for whom? Americans in the U.S.? Iraq was never a threat to anyone in the U.S. And it would be foolish and naive to claim as do Bush/Cheney that Iraqi insurgents are going to follow U.S. troops back to Kankakee or Salt Lake City.
The Congress should not allow this sleight of hand. Petraeus promised to report back to Congress and Bush should not be allowed to relegate him to the closet. I don't mind if Robert Gates also testifies but Condoleeza Rice is just another Bush shill who has no business testifying on what is happening on the ground in Iraq.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
9:52 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AMBASSADOR RYAN CROCKER, CONDOLEEZA RICE, DICK CHENEY, GEN. DAVID PETRAEUS, GEORGE W. BUSH, ROBERT GATES, WAR IN IRAQ
