Yesterday, in a five-to-four split decision, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Navy over its use of sonar in the Pacific off California. A number of groups had tried to hold the Navy to compliance with the National Environmental Impact Act because of their fear that the Navy's anti-submarine exercises would harm marine life with its high powered sonar signals.
In a decision reminiscent of the shameful Korematsu case - the WWII case where the Supremes weakly went along with Roosevelt's plan to lock up all Japanese Americans in camps for the duration of the war on the basis that the Court had no business second guessing the arguments of military military officers, - Chief Justice Roberts based his decision on and gave extreme deference to testimony of Navy officers who claimed that sonar testing was necessary for the training and ability of Navy personnel to find, detect and destroy "enemy" submarines. Marine mammals might be harmed but the Navy's arguments, based on fear that a more serious harm would occur to national security unless it could resume its sonar exercises, won the day, at least with five of the nine justices.
The case is WINTER, SECRETARY OF THE NAVY, v NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, INC., ET AL. Here is a link to the text of the case.
Roberts writes:
"The public interest in conducting training exercises with active sonar under realistic conditions plainly outweighs the interests advanced by the plaintiffs. Of course, military interests do not always trump other considerations,and we have not held that they do. In this case, however, the proper determination of where the public interest lies does not strike us as a close question. . . .
"President Theodore Roosevelt explained that "the only way in which a navy can ever be made efficient is by practice at sea, under all the conditions which would have to be met if war existed." President’s Annual Message, 42 Cong. Rec. 67, 81 (1907). We do not discount the importance of plaintiffs’ ecological, scientific, and recreational interests in marine mammals. Those interests, however, are plainly outweighed by the Navy’s need to conduct realistic training exercises to ensure that it is able to neutralize the threat posed by enemy submarines."
I disagree with Roberts. Why should preparation for war outweigh preserving whales and other sea life? Even though Roberts says, "military interests do not always trump other considerations, and we have not held that they do," I suspect that he and the other members of the Court who sided with him (Scalia, Alito, Thomas and Kennedy) would nearly always find the interests of the military outweigh and trump non-military interests. These justices are surely Republicans (other than Kennedy about whom I am not sure) and in my mind Republicans tend to be militaristic and try to solve problems with ships and tanks.
Roberts talks about "enemy submarines." The Navy has convinced him that there are forces of evil lurking and hiding in the deep seas ready to strike America. This is fanciful imagination at work in the halls of the Court. Bush-speak has invaded judicial chambers. America represents the good, the rest of the world forces of evil.
We don't need a Navy carrying out anti-submarine exercises off the coast of California. In the same way, we don't need an air force dropping bombs on villagers in some remote agrarian part of Pakistan.
Thursday, November 13, 2008
SUPREME COURT BACKS NAVY OVER PACIFIC OCEAN ENVIRONMENTALISTS
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:55 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, JUSTICE ALITO, JUSTICE ANTHONY KENNEDY, JUSTICE ANTONIN SCALIA, JUSTICE CLARENCE THOMAS, KOREMATSU, U.S. NAVY
Friday, November 16, 2007
BUSH GIVES SPEECH TO FEDERALIST SOCIETY
Robert Barnes reports in The Washington Post on Bush's speech last night to the Federalist Society. Writes Barnes:
"With 1,800 members crowding Union Station, the president of the United States on the dais and four Supreme Court justices singing its praises, last night might have marked the time for the Federalist Society to officially surrender its underdog persona.
"Founded in 1982 as a debating organization for conservative law students who said they were frustrated by prevailing liberal orthodoxy, the group celebrated its 25th anniversary with a black-tie dinner and a bracing message from President Bush about the group's twin passions: interpreting the Constitution as the founders wrote it and promoting conservatives to the federal bench. . . ."
"Alito was joined at the dinner by fellow justices Antonin Scalia, who years ago was a faculty adviser to a fledgling campus chapter at the University of Chicago, and Clarence Thomas, who received a rapturous reception from the group earlier in the day when where he sold and spoke about his new book, "My Grandfather's Son." (Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. appeared in a video tribute, and is scheduled to address the organization today.)"
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:56 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, GEORGE W. BUSH, JUSTICE ALITO, JUSTICE SCALIA, JUSTICE THOMAS
Tuesday, July 31, 2007
CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS SUFFERED SEIZURE BEFORE - WHY WAS PUBLIC NOT TOLD?
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:18 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, SEN. ARLEN SPECTER
Friday, June 29, 2007
JUSTICE THOMAS WOULD SAY STUDENTS' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS END AT SCHOOL HOUSE GATES
Another look at Morse vs. Frederick, the case where Chief Justice Roberts writes in a 5-4 decision that high school authorities "may take steps to safeguard those entrusted to their care from speech than can reasonably be regarded as encouraging illegal drug use."
Frederick, the high school student, unfurled a banner at a school-sponsored event that read, "BONG HiTS 4 JESUS." Morse, the principal, thought the banner and the saying encouraged illegal drug use, in violation of established school policy. She ripped the banner from Frederick's hands. Frederick sued the school district and Morse on grounds that the school and principal violated his rights to free speech under the First Amendment.
The other four conservative members of the Court (Alito, Scalia, Thomas and Kennedy) joined Roberts in holding for the principal and the school district and against the student. The holding is quite narrow when you read it closely. Perhaps happily no real damage has been done to a student's constitutional rights. Speech that encourages illegal drug use can be prohibited, but the Court said little about speech on any other topic.
Okay, assuming arguendo that the holding is correct (which I seriously doubt), how would this Court and its conservative justices rule in the event that Frederick held up a banner that read, "Pope Benedict is wrong on abortion"? Or "Bush is a War Criminal"? Or "Alaska Should Allow Minors to Drink"? Or "No Justice, No Peace"?
None of the above banners "encourages illegal drug use." Would the Court also deny any and all rights to free speech to students in high school? The opinion of the Chief Justice said nothing about statements other than those that encourage illegal drug use. However, Justice Thomas apparently would deny all rights of free speech to students in school.
Writes Justice Thomas:
"In the light of the history of American public education, it cannot be seriously be suggested that the First Amendment "freedom of speech" encompasses a student's right to speak in public school . . . I see no constitutional imperative requiring public schools to allow all student speech."
In other words, Thomas would overrule Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, where the Court recognized that a students right to free speech does not stop at the school house gates.
"I think the better approach is to dispense with Tinker altogether, and given the opportunity, I would do so."
Tinker involved a group of high school students wearing black arm bands to school to protest the VietNam War. The school ordered the arm bands off. The Tinker Court found the arm bands not disruptive of the school's educational mission, and therefore, allowable as an expression of a student's constitutional rights.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:25 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, JUSTICE THOMAS, TINKER V. DES MOINES SCHOOL DISTRICT
CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS PLAYS GAMES WITH BROWN VS. BOARD OF EDUCATION
Wednesday, June 27, 2007
DO HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS' RIGHTS OF FREE SPEECH STOP AT THE SCHOOL HOUSE GATE?
One of the major decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court for this term is Morse vs. Frederick, a case that tests a student's right to free speech in a high school setting.
Writes Chief Justice Roberts:
"At a school-sanctioned and school supervised setting, a high school principal saw some of her students unfurl a large banner convey a message she reasonably regarded as promoting illegal drug use. . . We hold that schools may take steps to safeguard those entrusted to their care from speech that can reasonably be regarded as encouraging illegal drug use. We conclude that the school officials in this case did not violate the First Amendment by confiscating the pro-drug banner and suspending the student responsible for it."
But to understand the case and see if Roberts got it right, we need to know what the banner said. "BONG HiTS 4 JESUS." That was it. According to the school superintendent, the poster "is a reference to a means of smoking marijuana." Furthermore, the superintendent concedes the student "was displaying a fairly silly message . . ." But the message was "promoting illegal drug usage in the midst of a school activity, for the benefit of television cameras covering the [event]."
The question is whether "BONG HiTS 4 JESUS" should be read as "promoting illegal drug usage," as both the school principal, school superintendent and Chief Justice Roberts seem to think.
Or is it free speech, uttered by a student, that does not promote anything, much less "illegal drug usage," and protected under the First Amendment?
Justice Stevens writes a stinging and well-reasoned dissent to Roberts, and the other four who joined the Chief Justice in the Court's decision (Scalia, Alito, Kennedy and Thomas). Stevens bases his dissent on the famous case in 1969, Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent Community School District, where students showed up at school with black armbands to protest the VietNam War. Tinker ruled that students do not lose their right of free speech when they enter the school house door. Stevens even brings up a quote of Justice Alito from a case decided when Alito was on the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, in which Alito then defended a student's right to free speech in school provided the speech was not disruptive:
"[R]egulation of student speech is generally permissible only when the speech would substantially disrupt of interfere with the work of the school or the rights of other students . . . Tinker requires a specific and significant fear of disruption, not just some remote apprehension of disturbance."
Stevens takes a common sense look at the message of the poster and finds it obscure and nonsensical:
"But it is one thing to restrict speech that advocates drug use. It is another thing entirely to prohibit an obscure message with a drug theme that a third party subjectively - and not very reasonably - thinks is tantamount to express advocacy. . . . To the extent the Court independently finds that 'BONG HiTS 4 JESUS" objectively amounts to the advocacy of illegal drug use - in other words, that it can most reasonably be interpreted as such - that conclusion practically refutes itself. This is a nonsense message, not advocacy."
Stevens finds the Roberts decision itself nonsensical because the Court seems to be ruling that any message regarding drug use is prohibited and not protected by the First Amendment if someone else subjectively perceives the message as encouraging illegal drug use:
"Although this case began with a silly, nonsensical banner, it ends with the Court inventing out of whole cloth a special First Amendment rule permitting the censorship of any student speech that mentions drugs, at least so long as someone could perceive that speech to contain a latent pro-drug message."
Stevens ends his dissenting opinion with a call to open dialog and speech not matter how controversial the topic:
"In the national debate about a serious issue, it is the expression of the minority's viewpoint that most demands the protection of the First Amendment. Whatever the better policy may be, a full and frank discussion of the costs and benefits of the attempt to prohibit the use of marijuana is far wiser than suppression of speech because it is unpopular."
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:48 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, JUSTICE ALITO, JUSTICE JOHN PAUL STEVENS, JUSTICE KENNEDY, JUSTICE SCALIA
