The New York Times runs an article today written by Jane Perlez on the mess in Pakistan.
Talking about Musharraf's illegal and unjustified firing of the Chief Justice of the Pakistan Supreme Court because the court would not go along with Musharraf's bid to remain in power in violation of the Pakistan Constitution, Perlez writes:
"Three other leading lawyers remain under house arrest, including Aitzaz Ahsan, the president of the Supreme Court Bar Association.
"Sixty of about 100 judges who served on the Supreme Court and four provincial high courts have been ordered to remain in their homes because they have refused to take the new oath of office under emergency rule, according to Wajihuddin Ahmed, a former Supreme Court judge.
"The chief justice and his court were the centerpiece of Mr. Musharraf’s emergency decree. The president accused the court, and Mr. Chaudhry in particular, of being ready to block his re-election, and dismissed the entire bench."
Chief Justice Chaudhry let it be known that the court would not agree with Musharraf's power grab, and that the court would rule against him. So Musharraf kicked out the members of the court and replaced them with his own people.
Yet Bush and Rice and the government of the United States has remained oddly quiet about this destruction of the rule of law in Pakistan. I thought Bush was the great proponent of "freedom" and "democracy"? Here when it comes to a supposed "ally," Bush says not one word of protest.
Writes Perlez:
"The United States and other Western governments have stopped short of calling for the restoration of the Supreme Court, even as they have pressed Mr. Musharraf to lift emergency rule in time for the elections.
"The Western governments have been reluctant to insist on the return of the old Supreme Court because, like Mr. Musharraf, they say Mr. Chaudhry was interfering in the executive branch, a Western diplomat said."
Wait! Where is Perlez getting her information? She writes that western governments have not insisted on Chaudhry's re-instatement because "they say Mr. Chaudhry was interfering in the executive branch . . ."
There is absolutely no credible evidence presented so far to show that Chief Justice Chaudhry was "interfering in the executive branch." Furthermore, who is this western diplomat who Ms. Perlez uses as a source for this statement? And how come Perlez does not offer any challenge to this charge?
Saturday, December 1, 2007
WHERE IS BUSH'S OUTRAGE OVER MUSHARRAF'S KICKING OUT PAKISTAN'S SUPREME COURT?
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
9:56 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE CHAUDHRY, CONDOLEEZA RICE, GEN. PERVEZ MUSHARRAF, GEORGE W. BUSH, PAKISTAN, RULE OF LAW
Friday, November 30, 2007
MUSHARRAF BLAMES CHIEF JUSTICE FOR HIS OWN CONSTITUTIONAL VIOLATIONS
In taking the oath to protect and defend Pakistan's Constitution, President Pervez Musharraf blames the recent constitutional crisis on Ifthikar Chaudhry, the deposed Chief Justice of Pakistan's Supreme Court.
Carlotta Gall writes in today's The New York Times:
"Mr. Musharraf defended his record in power, saying that he had always intended to lead the country toward democracy and to remove his uniform, but had to act in the interest of Pakistan’s stability.
"He said he had to impose emergency rule on Nov. 3, and delay removing his uniform, because of a clash between state institutions, namely the judiciary and the government, and the growing threat of terrorism.
"He blamed Mr. Chaudhry, the former chief justice, for derailing his planned transition to democracy and suggested it was a conspiracy hatched against him. (Emphases added).
"“I feel this derailment could have led the nation to chaos,” Mr. Musharraf said. He said he had not wanted to impose the emergency rule but in light of a growing threat from terrorism and the clashes between the judiciary and the executive, he had acted in the country’s interests.
"“This was an extraordinary circumstance, ladies and gentlemen, it needed extraordinary measures to control,” he said. “No half-hearted measures could have delivered.”
Musharraf blames the constitutional crisis on the Chief Justice because Chaudhry would not go along with Musharraf's scheme to remain head of the army at the same time Musharraf was running for president.
"Let's kill all the lawyers [and judges]" is the operative phrase when the king cannot get them to rule in his favor. And this is what Musharraf has done. Because the Pakistani Bar would not support his power-grabbing ambitions, he has imprisoned them and had his police attack them. Then he tries in Bush-like fashion to blame them for the destruction of the rule of law.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
12:53 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHIEF JUSTICE CHAUDHRY, GEN. PERVEZ MUSHARRAF, PAKISTANI CONSTITUTION, PAKISTANI LAWYERS, RULE OF LAW
Thursday, November 29, 2007
MUSHARRAF SAYS HE WILL LIFT MARTIAL LAW, BUT WHERE ARE THE LAWYERS AND JUDGES HE THREW IN JAIL?
Pakistan's Pervez Musharraf has agreed to rescind his emergency rule order on December 16th, reports Pamela Constable for The Washington Post today.
"Musharraf stepped down as army chief on Wednesday, meeting a key demand of opposition groups and Western allies. As he was sworn in to a new five-year term on Thursday, he pledged to seek reconciliation with opponents and move the country toward the "complete essence of democracy." But he also lashed out at the West for its "obsession" with a version of democracy and human rights that he said does not fit Pakistani society."
Oh, is it "western obsession" to object to the firing of the Chief Justice of the Pakistan Supreme Court when he disagrees with allowing you Musharraf to run for president at the same time as you are head of the army? And I wonder how Pakistani lawyers will understand a "version of democracy" that says there should not be free speech and free association? Or how about the lawyers and judges now in incarceration because they dared to disagree with Musharraf's stunted understanding of "democracy" - how will they understand Musharraf's version of democracy?
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:00 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEN. PERVEZ MUSHARRAF, PAKISTAN, PAKISTANI LAWYERS, RULE OF LAW
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
NATO PLANES KILL 14 AFHGAN CIVILIANS IN RECKLESS BOMBING RAID
Here's another case of NATO (read U.S.) war planes dropping bombs on innocent Afghan civilians. Abdul Waheed Wafa writes in today's The New York Times that 14 Afghan workers were killed on Monday by a NATO air strike.
Waheed Wafa writes:
"The strike occurred late Monday night in the Norgram district of Nuristan when the Afghan workers of Amerifa Road Construction Company were sleeping in tents after a day’s work.
"“Fourteen of our mechanics and laborers were killed as they were asleep in their tents,” said Nurullah Jalali, the executive director of the construction company. “We just collected pieces of flesh from our tired workers and put them in 14 coffins.”
"The governor of Nuristan, Tamim Nuristani, said he could confirm that 13 workers had been “mistakenly” killed when NATO forces bombed the area based on what he said was an intelligence report that insurgents were infiltrating the area.
"“All these victims are civilians, and they were from nearby provinces,” Mr. Nuristani said.
A NATO spokesman said its forces had struck the area in an attack on what it believed were Taliban insurgents but could not confirm that the road workers had been killed."
I have commented many times before on the destruction to innocent life from NATO and U.S. war planes in Afghanistan. When the U.S. drops a bomb, the chances are that there will always be civilian casualties including women and children.
This is sufficient reason to end all air strikes. The airplane should not be used for dropping bombs or inflicting death. The U.S. Air Force and other military services should stop all combat flights over Afghanistan and Iraq. The killing of civilians is a certain result of a U.S. pilot dropping bombs on houses, villages, towns and cities. Because it is a foreseeable effect, the laws of war should be upgraded to ban such flights. No country, including the U.S., should be allowed to intentionally kill civilians even if insurgents or enemy soldiers are present.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
10:59 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AFGHANISTAN, AL QAEDA IN IRAQ, U.S. BOMBING, US AIR FORCE, WAR IN IRAQ
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
HYPOCRITICAL MITT RULES OUT MUSLIM IN HIS CABINET BASED ON SMALL NUMBERS IN U.S.
ThinkProgress, one of my favorite liberal news blogs, picks up on an interview of Mitt Romney by Mansoor Ijaz, in which Romney says that based on the number of Muslims in the U.S., he could not foresee adding a Muslim to his cabinet if elected president. The interview is reported on the Christian Science Monitor web site.
Ijaz writes:
"I asked Mr. Romney whether he would consider including qualified Americans of the Islamic faith in his cabinet as advisers on national security matters, given his position that "jihadism" is the principal foreign policy threat facing America today. He answered, "…based on the numbers of American Muslims [as a percentage] in our population, I cannot see that a cabinet position would be justified. But of course, I would imagine that Muslims could serve at lower levels of my administration.""
Ijaz picks up on Mitt's hypocrisy. Here he turns down Muslims as part of his cabinet because he says they do no represent a sufficient percentage of the population. Yet Mitt as a Mormon is part of a relatively small church in the United States, and based on the number of Mormons, should not be considered for any post in anybody else's cabinet, nor should Mitt be able to be elected president based solely on the number of Mormons to the general American population.
Writes Ijaz:
"Romney, whose Mormon faith has become the subject of heated debate in Republican caucuses, wants America to be blind to his religious beliefs and judge him on merit instead. Yet he seems to accept excluding Muslims because of their religion, claiming they're too much of a minority for a post in high-level policymaking. More ironic, that Islamic heritage is what qualifies them to best engage America's Arab and Muslim communities and to help deter Islamist threats."
ThinkProgress adds:
"Note to Romney: As a Mormon running for President, you’re going to need to come up with a better justification for religious bigotry against Muslims.
"According to the CIA World Factbook (which uses 2002 numbers), Mormons comprise just 2 percent of the U.S. population, while Jews and Muslims comprise 1 percent each. Based on 2001 numbers, there were 2.8 million Mormons and 1.1 million Muslims in the United States. Surveys since that time indicate that the number of Muslims may have eclipsed the number of Mormons living in the U.S."
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
11:06 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR, MANSOOR IJAZ, MITT ROMNEY, MORMONS, MUSLIMS, THINKPROGRESS
Monday, November 26, 2007
WHY NOTHING FROM GEORGE AND LAURA BUSH ON SAUDI TREATMENT OF 19-YEAR-OLD WOMAN GIVEN 200 LASHES?
Now we have the Saudi Foreign Minister in Annapolis for the meeting tomorrow. And still no apology or retraction of the unfair and barbaric sentence imposed upon that 19-year-old Saudi young woman caught in a car with a man not a relative. And this after the 19-year-old was gang-raped and sexually humiliated by seven males. A Saudi court convicted the girl and gave her a punishment of 200 lashes plus time in prison.
To see how the Saudi court treats this victim and makes her into the criminal is unjust. The penalty of 200 lashes is not only medieval and cruel, it is barbaric and backward. It violates the international Declaration of Human Rights and human rights of woman.
Here is a section from Declaration of the Rights of Woman, 1791, written by Olympe de Gouges way back in 1791:
"Man, are you capable of being just? It is a woman who poses the question; you will not deprive her of that right at least. Tell me, what gives you sovereign empire to oppress my sex? Your strength? Your talents? Observe the Creator in his wisdom; survey in all her grandeur that nature with whom you seem to want to be in harmony, and give me, if you dare, an example of this tyrannical empire. Go back to animals, consult the elements, study plants, finally glance at all the modifications of organic matter, and surrender to the evidence when I offer you the means; search, probe, and distinguish, if you can, the sexes in the administration of nature. Everywhere you will find them mingled; everywhere they cooperate in harmonious togetherness in this immortal masterpiece.
"Man alone has raised his exceptional circumstances to a principle. Bizarre, blind, bloated with science and degenerated--in a century of enlightenment and wisdom--into the crassest ignorance, he wants to command as a despot a sex which is in full possession of its intellectual faculties; he pretends to enjoy the Revolution and to claim his rights to equality in order to say nothing more about it."
This Declaration was written some 217 years before the Saudi court imposed this unfair sentence on this young woman this year for exercising her basic human rights.
Where is George Bush, great defender of freedom and democracy, in speaking out against this Saudi outrage? And where is Laura Bush, defender of the rights of women throughout the Moslem world? So far, we have heard nothing from either George or Laura. The government of the United States is silent on this most unjust violation of human rights. What hypocrisy!
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
2:59 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: GEORGE W. BUSH, LAURA BUSH, OLYMPE DE GOUGES, RIGHTS OF WOMAN, SAUDI COURTS
Sunday, November 25, 2007
SAUDI ARABIA DEFENDS 200 LASHES ON YOUNG WOMAN WHO WAS GANG-RAPED
Saudi officials have defended the decision of a Saudi court to impose 200 lashes on a 19-year-old woman who was gang-raped.
Reports Al Jazeera:
"Saudi Arabia has defended a court decision to sentence a woman who was gang-raped to 200 lashes, saying she was having an extramarital affair in violation of Islamic laws."The woman in the case is married and has confessed to establishing a relationship in violation of [Islamic] sharia law," the Saudi justice ministry said in a statement."
This punishment is barbaric and medieval. The young woman is the victim of a brutal sex crime, and the Saudis sentence her to 200 lashes for being in a car with a male not a relative.
Yet we have heard nothing from Bush or Rice condemning this injustice. And where is the voice of Laura Bush who is supposed to be the defender of women's rights around the world? All we get from Bush & Co. is silence.
We need to hear more protests from the Democratic presidential contenders. Clinton, Obama, Edwards and the rest have already protested this judicial barbarism emanating from the Saudi Kingdom. But they need to redouble their cries of outrage.
If Saudi Arabia allows this sentence or any punishment to be inflicted upon this 19-year-old, the world community should make Saudi Arabia an outcast and pariah.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
8:11 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: CONDOLEEZA RICE, GEORGE W. BUSH, JOHN EDWARDS, SAUDI ARABIA, SAUDI COURTS, SEN. BARACK OBAMA, SEN. HILLARY CLINTON
ARCHBISHOP OF CANTERBURY CONDEMNS U.S. HEGEMONIC FOREIGN POLICY
The BBC reports today on criticism by the Archbishop of Canterbury about hegemonic and destructive U.S. foreign policy.
"Archbishop of Canterbury Dr Rowan Williams has launched a stinging attack on US policy, comparing it unfavourably with the British Empire . . . ."
"Dr Williams said the US, as the only "global hegemonic power", was trying to accumulate influence and control, rather than territory. But he said: "That is not working," describing the result as "the worst of all worlds".
"He told the magazine the US had lost the moral high ground since the 11 September attacks and needed to take steps including "generous aid" to "the societies that have been ravaged", a "check on the economic exploitation of defeated territories" and a "demilitarisation" of its presence in them in order to recover.
"The US believed that in Iraq it could then leave others to "put it back together", he said."
The Archbishop expresses what any thinking person sees and knows: the United States establishes military bases in any country that allows it, thinks it can solve all problems through military force, and thinks it itself is the greatest and all-knowing country in the world in spite of evidence to the contrary.
This "American exceptionalism" allows the U.S. and government officials to commit the most outrageous violations of human rights, engage in torture and other crimes against individual rights, bomb countries it deems "enemies," and throughout all, encourage its citizens to think that the U.S. is the sole beacon of democracy and freedom
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
1:59 PM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: ARCHBISHOP OF CANTERBURY, BBC, ROWAN WILLIAMS, U.S. FOREIGN POLICY, U.S. HEGEMONY
Saturday, November 24, 2007
AUSTRALIANS REJECT JOHN HOWARD, BUSH ALLY, AS PRIME MINISTER
Good news from Australia. Voters have defeated John Howard, prime minister for the last 11 years, and so not only has he lost his post as prime minister but even his seat as a member of the Australian parliament.
Howard was always lapping at the side of Bush and Cheney. He committed Australian troops to Iraq and refused to consider pulling them out. He sided with Bush and Cheney in rejecting the Kyoto Treaty. He was a favorite the Bush administration and he supported all the other disastrous Bush/Cheney policies.
Congratulations to the people of Australia for kicking Howard out of office. Another Bush/Cheney ally loses office!
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
11:27 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: AUSTRALIA, DICK CHENEY, GEORGE W. BUSH, JOHN HOWARD, KYOTO TREATY, WAR IN IRAQ
WASHINGTON WEEK ON PBS SHOULD DROP BOEING AND MINING ASSOCIATION AS SPONSORS
What should a public affairs/"news" program do about reporting on companies that sponsor its telecast? That's the problem facing Washington Week with Gwen Ifill which is underwritten by Boeing Corporation and National Mining Association. If one of Washington Week's panelists wants to report on some misdeeds of Boeing or of the NMA, will Gwen Ifill or her producers at PBS allow it?
Or to say it another way. It is improper for Washington Week to take sponsorship money from companies like Boeing or organizations like NMA because there is an inherent conflict of interest.
Boeing makes weapons of war and is one of the big suppliers to the Defense Department of airplanes and other armaments. It has made millions of dollars from selling these things to the U.S. government in the War in Iraq. I would suspect that Washington Week would be sensitive and reluctant about having one of its guest reporters report on war-profiteering or maybe even on the anti-war movement.
The same goes for the NMA. Where are the stories about the Crandall Canyon Mine disaster in Utah or on other hazards of modern mining in the U.S. and in other parts of the world, such as Ukraine or Mexico, sites of recent coal mining fatal accidents?
Even if Washington Week claims it devotes sufficient air time towards these stories, the doubt will still remain among reasonable viewers that there is a conflict of interest biased against full disclosure and discussion.
Washington Week needs to re-think allowing certain companies and organizations, such as Boeing and the NMA, from sponsoring its telecasts. Otherwise the suspicion and appearance of improper influence will linger on every broadcast.
Posted by
BOB EDER
at
9:10 AM PERMALINK
0
comments
Labels: BOEING CORP., GWEN IFILL, NATIONAL MINING ASSOCIATION, NMA
